Welcome! Imaginary Shirt is a project where I research visual elements from high schools’ histories and then use them to make new t-shirt concepts. If you’re associated with one of these schools and would like to make any of these imaginary shirts a reality, let me know! I’d love to help you accomplish that. This companion newsletter gives some more details on process and on the schools featured. Enjoy!
Instagram Week in Review
Monday, 16 October 2023—Palmyra Panthers, Palmyra, NJ

Much of the Palmyra High buiilding was destroyed in a fire in 1957. The December 11, 1957 New Jersey Herald-News had the story on what caused the fire:
George D. Lehmann, 16, dropped from the Palmyra High School football team in midseason for missing practice, was held without bail today after telling police he set Monday’s fire that destroyed 15 classrooms and the school library.
Police reported that Lehmann said he and a companion entered the school with a key before midnight Sunday to search for future tests in order to improve their grades.
The two heard a noise, became frightened and fled after dropping paper torches, the boy was quoted.
The fire went undiscovered until after 3:30 a.m. and burned out of control until 5 a.m. Damage was so extensive that classes have been suspended for the 850 pupils.
I wondered what became of George Lehmann, and was surprised that it was not hard to find out. Lehmann had a long professional basketball career, even reaching the NBA. He played two seasons for the Hawks, both in St. Louis and part of the first year that they moved to Atlanta. But the November 19, 1968 Atlanta Constitution reported on the end of that career:
Reserve guard George Lehmann has played his last basketball game for the Atlanta Hawks, general manager Marty Blake reported Monday.
“George called in Friday afternoon that he was sick,” Blake said, “and we haven’t heard from him since. We’ve tried unsuccessfully to reach him at his Atlanta apartment, and we can’t locate him in Riverside, N.J. where his family lives.
“So I presume he has left town, and I am suspending him indefinitely. This means he’ll never play for the Hawks again. And it means he’s through in professional basketball unless we can make a trade for him.”
Basketball Reference notes that Lehmann’s last game in the NBA was November 13, 1968.
See more designs from the Palmyra set here.
Tuesday, 17 October 2023—Vineland Fighting Clan, Vineland, NJ

Vineland, New Jersey was once a real poultry hotbed, nicknamed “The Egg Basket of America.” For years before they became the Fighting Clan, Vineland High’s teams were known as the Poultry Clan, which I think is way, way cooler.
In 1955, Vineland hosted the second annual Vineland Poultry & Egg Festival. The program was packed, featuring exhibits; a chicken barbecue (“prepared by Waldo Chick, barbecue expert from Wells, Me.”); a Swedish gymnastics exhibition; the Miss Baby Chick contest; a parade of nations; an address by the governor; the crowning of the Poultry Prince and Princess; and dancing in the park until midnight.
But the highlight of the festival was Millie, the world’s largest mechanical chicken. The June 25, 1955 Vineland Daily Journal described the proceedings:
“Millie,” the world’s largest chicken, perched at the intersection of Sixth and Landis ave. this morning, dispensing some 3,600 eggs in one dozen cartons for mortorists as a prelude to the big second annual South Jersey and Vineland Poultry and Egg Festival opening in Landis Park this afternoon.
An estimated 1,000 persons, many of them children enthralled by the 16-foot high bird, lined the curbs as the mechanical hen dispensed the eggs conveniently packaged in one-dozen and half-dozen cartons.
There was one final Poultry & Egg Festival in 1956 before it sadly ended.
See more designs from the Vineland set here.
Wednesday, 18 October 2023—Westfield Blue Devils, Westfield, NJ

Among Westfield’s graduates is Bob Clotworthy, winner of an Olympic bronze medal in diving in Helsinki in 1952 and a gold medal in Melbourne in 1956. The December 3, 1956 Melbourne Age shared some of the details:
The divers amazed a capacity crowd as they sprung into the air, then twisted and rolled in fantastic feats of body control, before dropping smoothly into the water.
In his final dive, Clotworthy spun into a one and a half forward somersault with double twist to clinch his Gold Medal and gain the highest score for a single dive during the competition—20.80.
The December 1, 1956 Plainfield Courier-News captured Clotworthy’s parents’ reaction: “We knew he could do it. We’re tickled to death.”
In a January 30, 1957 article, he Courier-News noted Clotworthy’s sportsmanship:
The former national three-meter champ and five time AAU king was a surprise Olympic winner because he finished third in the Olympic tryouts in Detroit. “I wound up third because I did a pike instead of a tuck in one of my dives,” intimated Bob. “It was a case of losing my power of concentration for a split second.”
What Bobby didn’t tell us was that officials at the tryouts thought that he didn’t clearly hear the dive announced because of the noise made by fans and offered him another chance to do it. But Bobby admitted that it was his mistake. Despite losing valuable points he put forth a tremendous performance the rest of the way to wind up third.
His honesty and ability to come through in the clutch are the stuff champions are made of and Bob’s teammates were just as jubilant as he was when his Olympic winning point score of 159.56 was posted.
See more designs from the Westfield set here.
Thursday, 19 October 2023—Plainfield Cardinals, Plainfield, NJ

Plainfield High graduate and teacher Adella Liebenow Wotherspoon was the youngest survivor of the 1904 General Slocum disaster. The Slocum was a passenger steamboat which caught fire and sank in the East River. Of the ship’s nearly 1,400 passengers, 955 are thought to have died in the disaster. Wotherspoon was only six or seven months old when she survived the incident.
On June 15, 1905, on the one-year anniversary of the sinking of the Slocum, Wotherspoon helped to unveil a monument to the those who had died in the fire but had not been identified. The next day’s New York Times reported:
Ten thousand people saw through their tears a baby with a doll tucked under her arm unveil the monument to the unidentified dead of the Slocum disaster yesterday afternoon in the Lutheran Cemetery, Middle Village, L.I.
As the flag unfolded, disclosing the monument, with its four symbolic figures of Despair, Grief, Courage, and Belief in the Hereafter, a marble figure with finger pointed heavenward, the baby dropped her doll, and, pointing her finger toward the monument above her, cried so that all heard her:
“See—pretty.”
The 300 members of the United Singing Societies of New York and Brooklyn bravely tried to sing and succeeded after a few bars in hushing the sobbing of many.
The monument still stands, and can be seen here.
See more designs from the Plainfield here.
Friday, 20 October 2023—Payette Pirates, Payette, ID

A July 4, 1974 Sports Illustrated item mentioned Payette High’s dome structure, which remains on it’s campus:
With costs of the Louisiana Superdome soaring over the $160 million mark and the end not yet in sight, it is nice to report this story of low finance in Payette, Idaho. A community of 4,700 just across the Snake River from Ontario, Ore., Payette is this very week moving into a dome of its own. The building, 150 feet in diameter and 86 feet tall, has been turned into a new gymnasium for the high school. There is room enough for three basketball courts, one full-sized, the others not very much smaller, and 2,500 spectators. Badminton anybody? Eight games can be played simultaneously. On a large balcony running around the courts there is space for, among many activities, wrestling, gymnastics and band practice. The cost: $300,000.
If that seems unbelievable, it is not. The project took shape 14 years ago in the mind of John Campbell, then a young teacher, who shepherded his physics classes to Dooley Mountain in Oregon to observe work being done on an Air Force radar dome. Campbell eventually became superintendent of the Payette school system, and last year, when the Dooley dome was declared surplus, he struck. After much ado the town got the dome for the cost of carrying it away. It gives the little high school one of the finest gyms in the state and is the biggest hit in town since Harmon Killebrew was clouting thunderous flies into the surrounding desert.
A December 1974 Los Angeles Times News Service article divulged a compliment that Superintendent Campbell had received on the project:
“When you first started on that thing I thought it was the craziest thing in the world,” Campbell’s barber told him last week. “Now my hat’s off to you, John. I have to admit it’s really something.”
See more designs from the Payette set here.
Saturday, 21 October 2023—Norwich Free Academy Wildcats, Norwich, CT

The June 6, 1887 Hartford Courant noted:
Miss Marion Elsie Blackman, a teacher in the Norwich free academy, died last week from the lodging of an orange seed in the projection from the intestine called the appendix veriformis. A similar case at Brooklyn resulted fatally not long ago. A year or two ago Dr. Paddock of Norwich was affected in the same way, but his life was saved by an operation.
This is at least sort of interesting, but what is astounding is how widely this incident was reported. Just weeks later, it was reported in a newspaper from Salt Lake City, Utah. But not only was it a newspaper from Utah, it was a newspaper in Utah printed in Swedish. The June 23, 1887 Svenska Harolden reported (my apologies for lack of diacritical marks):
En omtalig flicka Froken Marion Blackman i Norwich, Conn, afled forliden vecka for det hon rakat svalja ner en apelsinkarna.
Marion Blackman was the twin sister of Monroe Earle Blackman. She died just weeks short of her thirty-ninth birthday. Monroe had a daughter in 1878 who he named Marion Elizabeth Blackman—it seems likely after his sister. Marion’s namesake would herself die from a strange illness; she would be just thirty-seven. The September 7, 1915 Brooklyn Daily Eagle had the story:
Marion Elizabeth Blackman, M.D., daughter of the late Monroe E. Blackman, M.D., died on Friday at a private hospital in Buffalo, N.Y., where she had gone the week before for expert examination, having been an invalid for some months in the sanitarium at Castile, N.Y. Her case had baffled the skill of many physicians and not until an autopsy was performed was her condition understood. Chronic interstitial nephritis was the cause of death.
The American Journal of Kidney Diseases Atlas of Renal Pathology says of chronic interstitial nephritis, “The diagnosis is made when specific underlying causes cannot be identified,” so I’m not sure they ever really did figure it out.
Norwich Free Academy now offers the Marion E. Blackman Prize, “awarded to two high-achieving seniors in English courses.”
See more designs from the Norwich Free Academy set here.
Sunday, 22 October 2023—Twin Falls Bruins, Twin Falls, ID

In 1947, people were seeing flying saucers everywhere, and that included Twin Falls, Idaho. You can see some of the FBI files for that era here, and they’re quite interesting.
A July 11, 1947 memo from the FBI files with the subject “FLYING DISCS” says:
SAC Bannister of the Butte Office called at noon today and stated that a REDACTED Twin Falls, Idaho, at 2:45 a.m. Mountain Time today heard a noise in the back of her home. She thought a collision had occurred and investigated and found in the back yard of the home next door an object described as follows:
A disc 30 1/2” in diameter, circular in shape, it is dished like a saucer and actually there is a saucer within a saucer in the manner of cymbals. On one surface there is attached a plastic dome described as about 14” in diameter and affixed by 8 bolts in a rather rough manner. The bolts can best be described as similar to stove bolts. On the other surface is another dome of metal which is gold in color on one side and on the inside is silver in color, which looks like tin. Through the plastic dome can be observed three tubes similar to radio tubes and there is some wiring. The disc generally is 10” thick and at the point where the domes are located about 14” in thickness. There is an object on it similar to electric coil which has some type of an arm on it and bears the words “Inspected T5.” Some of the wiring has been burned off and it looks as thought something might be missing.
REDACTED stated that if this were the work of some prankster he went to quite a bit of trouble. He stated the press is aware of this incident. He stated that the disc had been picked up and was now at the Police Department, Twin Falls, Idaho. He was instructed to notify the local Army authorities of the existence of this disc.
By the end of the day, four teenagers (Twin Falls High students?) had confessed to perpetrating the hoax. Their names were withheld and they were not prosecuted due to their age. But the July 15, 1947 Twin-Falls Times-News wasn’t sure they were buying it:
There is only one conclusion. Either the army doesn’t know what these “saucers” are all about and is pretty much in a dither, or it made a grandstand play of the Twin Falls incident to keep the public ignorant or confused—or both.
Back in Salt Lake City several days later the “brass,” in true army fashion, released a picture of the “disc” which had been brought there from Twin Falls. In the arms of a captain, the “hoax” disc was made to appear as another triumph of the army.
There aren’t many songs that I like more than I like this one:
See more designs from the Twin Falls set here.
See you next week! Tell your friends!